Page 1 of 1
Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Wed Dec 12, 2012 11:31 pm
by John Grima
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Sun Dec 16, 2012 4:03 am
by John Grima
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Tue Dec 18, 2012 9:28 pm
by John Grima
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Wed Dec 19, 2012 8:20 am
by Kent Wiik
Hi John,
Very, very impressing work and I am glad you also made a Panther one as I might consider install one of them in my own Panther build.
Regarding the colours...have you seen this WW2 colour photo before?
It looks like the valve covers was made from aluminium and kept without paint, also a lot of other items was silver looking.
Kind regards
Kent
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 6:07 am
by John Grima
Thanks Kent, I have seen that photo before, but from most of the war time images, surviving engines, and panther manual images most have the engines painted all over dark grey, and cyclones in a light grey.
Listed below are some of my reference images
http://www.toadmanstankpictures.com/panther_214.jpg
http://www.toadmanstankpictures.com/panther_222.jpg
Panther manual found in manuals
http://www.wheatcroftcollection.com/
On some surviving engines I have seen the rocker arm covers left in all aluminum as well. Personally I like the uniform look of the all grey engines, just like on American engines being all OD.
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 7:48 am
by Paul Morris
Hello John.
Looking really good, lots of time and effort to produce those well done.
Thing is I can't stop admiring the 8 rad in the background.
Cheers Paul.
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2012 12:47 pm
by Kent Wiik
Hi again John,
Sorry, donĀ“t want to stir things up here...
but this is rather interesting.
Here in Sweden we have a Maybach HL230 from a KT we had from France in 1946. It is said to probably be the only one left in the world without any changes since the war.
It has all its original paint still intact:
http://www.plasticwarfare.se/2011/09/sp ... ting-2011/
Interesting to note are the (once) shiny aluminum cam shaft covers, something that is also seen in the Wheatcroft Panther manual, picture (Bild) 19, you kindly linked.
Those photos can also be seen in the Spielberger book "Der Panzer-Kampfwagen Panther und seine Abarten" page 43.
I always try to find WW2 photos or photos of an untouched relic as template.
Museum "restored" items are seldom accurate as 60 years of kind? handle and caring has taken its toll...
Kind regards
Kent
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Tue Dec 25, 2012 3:58 am
by John Grima
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Tue Dec 25, 2012 7:05 pm
by Mike Stannard (toyrific)
John
A fantastic build, congratulations, I can imagine how much research, time and effort you put into creating this work of art. My take on the color of parts is they would likely come direct from the factory in natural metal, considering the heat generated by the engine, as most engines were in that time period. Painting of the engine may have been done after the tanks were in the hands of the units, but remember heat resistant paint would be required or it would simply burn off. I do remember my first car, a 1949 Morris 8 that I paid 17 Pounds and 10 Shillings for in 1962, it had a black shiny rocker cover which had some sort of acrylic coating, I doubt they would have gone to this extent on a war time military vehicle. My 2 cents worth.
Mike
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Tue Dec 25, 2012 8:57 pm
by John Grima
Thanks Mike, from my experience I have seen the opposite. About three years ago My father purchased an old 1947 Cletrac bulldozer. Before we restored it The dozer and engine was still in it's original paint. The only parts that were heavily weathered / cooked were the exhaust manifold system.
Even after the restoration I can say that the only parts that the paint will burn off of is the exhausts manifold and exhaust stacks. Parts like the engine block, rocker arm covers, starter...etc keep their color very well.
The only time parts on the engine would have different colors is when they were replaced with NOS parts.
I doubt that they were painted exclusively in the field because the images from the manual show the factory fresh engine in a fresh coat of professionally applied paint.
As for painting these kits, both versions are accurate, just depends on what you are representing or personal taste.
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Wed Dec 26, 2012 9:34 am
by Kent Wiik
John and Mike,
I love interesting and constructive discussions like this.
Mike, no engines left factory with all paint needed applied and no need for any "in field Picasso" to spend man hours here...
Here is a photo how Auto Union AG had their Maybach HL 230 as seen here today in one of their engines in their Museum.
Auto Union made half of a total number of about 9000 Maybach HL 230 made during the war.
Regarding WW2 photos of in field installed Maybach here is another:
And regarding Maybach manual here is another photo:
And last, a photo taken just after the war ended from the MNH Panther production.
Please note the line of factory fresh Maybach HL 230:
Kind regards and a Happy New Year.
/Kent
Re: Maybach HL230 w.Cyclone air filters
Posted: Wed Dec 26, 2012 3:41 pm
by Steve Norris
Kent,John,Mike.
Could it be that the different finishes on the engines are a result of different manufacturers or perhaps even overhaul as original wartime photos clearly show both types of finish.
Great product and subject
Regards
Steve